Karmelo Anthony Gets New Judge as New Trial Fight Continues

Judge John Roach Jr. has been removed from the case as Anthony's defense prepares to seek a new trial.

MCKINNEY, Texas — Karmelo Anthony's case took a major turn Wednesday after a visiting judge granted his defense team's request to remove Judge John Roach Jr. from future proceedings.

A new judge will now handle the next stage of Anthony's case as his defense seeks a new trial.

Judge Roach Removed From Case

Judge Sid Harle granted the defense's request Wednesday to recuse Judge John Roach Jr. from the case.

The defense argued that comments Roach made after Anthony's conviction could raise questions about his ability to remain impartial during the upcoming post-conviction proceedings.

A New Judge Takes Over

Retired Kaufman County District Judge Michael B. Chitty has been assigned to handle the next proceedings.

Chitty is scheduled to preside over the hearing concerning Anthony's request for a new trial.

The New Trial Has Not Been Granted

The change in judges does not mean Anthony has received a new trial.

His defense still has to convince the court that the conviction should be overturned and that another trial is warranted.

For now, Anthony's 35-year prison sentence remains in place.

What Happens Next?

The focus now moves to Anthony's new-trial request.

The hearing is scheduled for August 20, with Judge Chitty presiding.

The court will consider the defense's arguments as Anthony attempts to overturn his murder conviction.

The Bottom Line

Today's ruling gives Anthony's defense a new judge for the next stage of the case — but it does not overturn his conviction.

Now, the attention turns to whether his legal team can convince the new judge to grant a new trial.

Q Spot News will continue following the case as the next hearing unfolds.